Newcastle - Bilbao: What is happening to Eddie Howe?

Eddie Howe is currently navigating one of the most confusing periods since taking over Newcastle. After nearly four impressive years, the English manager, considered the greatest coach in the club’s modern history, suddenly became the target of criticism following last weekend’s loss to West Ham.

No one can deny Howe’s impact. Under his reign, Newcastle transformed from an average team into a Premier League Top 4 contender, secured Champions League qualification, and developed a distinct playing style. He rarely made errors in speech or tactics. However, the display against West Ham raised the question: What is happening to Eddie Howe?

The match at London Stadium was regarded as a tactical disaster. Newcastle’s players appeared lifeless, frequently mispassing, and hardly creating any significant chances. The more serious issue was Howe’s personnel and tactical changes in the second half, which had been his strength over the past four years.

Instead of revitalizing the team, Howe’s substitutions caused further confusion. Newcastle dominated possession but lacked structure, while West Ham easily launched counterattacks and sealed the victory.

Even more surprisingly, Howe altered the formation four times during the match: starting from 4-3-3, switching to 3-5-2, then 4-2-4, and finally 4-1-4-1. At one point, there were four players on the pitch who had experience playing as right-backs. Harvey Barnes was shifted from right to left wing, Malick Thiaw and Joelinton frequently swapped roles, and Sandro Tonali ended the game playing as a full-back.