Is Okamoto Kazuma generally rated higher than Murakami? Here's how MLB scouts evaluate him

Yomiuri Giants power hitter Okamoto Kazuma, aiming to join MLB via the posting system, took the designated hitter role and batted fourth in the "Japan-Korea Exchange Game" on the 15th. His performance before the game drew interest from numerous MLB scouts, one of whom explicitly said, "I have a higher opinion of Okamoto than Murakami."

The Yomiuri Giants formally authorized Okamoto's challenge to MLB through the posting system on October 22. On the day of the "Japan-Korea Exchange Game," several MLB scouts gathered behind home plate at Tokyo Dome, representing teams such as the New York Yankees, Philadelphia Phillies, San Diego Padres, Los Angeles Angels, Toronto Blue Jays, Chicago White Sox, and Los Angeles Dodgers, all observing Okamoto's performance.

However, Okamoto only had one at-bat that day; after hitting a fly ball to center-right field in the second inning, he was substituted by a pinch hitter. After the game, he explained, "This was the planned arrangement, nothing unusual happened, and I am feeling fine." Still, scouts circulated questions about whether Okamoto might have any physical issues. Previously, a scout emphasized, "Although Murakami Munetaka is five years younger and likely has a more valuable overall contract, our team currently has a greater need for Okamoto."

Currently, Tokyo Yakult Swallows' superstar third baseman Murakami Munetaka, who has also completed his posting application, remains a hot topic in the media. However, some scouts have expressed concerns, questioning Murakami's ability to handle fastballs, specifically, "There are doubts about whether he can effectively hit high-velocity inside pitches."

Nevertheless, some scouts note that both Murakami and Okamoto possess the qualities needed to succeed in MLB, with the most crucial being their "thick skin." "Playing in the U.S., where the environment is completely different, overly sensitive players tend to struggle. In this regard, both Okamoto and Murakami have demonstrated strong resilience."

Though their training attitudes receive similar assessments, Okamoto earns higher praise among commentators. "Okamoto comes across as more laid-back, not overexerting himself, maintaining a relaxed posture during training, which is excellent." The same scout added, "Those who can stay unaffected by their surroundings and perform anywhere are ultimately the ones who succeed."

Some American media even predict Okamoto could secure a four-year contract worth $90 million. As the season ends and opportunities to evaluate players in actual games become scarcer, scouts are increasingly focused on making the most of these final observation chances.